Five steps, no guesswork — you always know exactly what comes next. Tap a step to see what it involves.
12345
You pay securely. Payment is confirmed instantly, and your receipt with the written fee breakup lands in your inbox.
Step zero: are you a resident or nonresident alien?
Everything flows from this classification. The IRS does not care about your visa label or where you consider "home" — it applies two tests.
The green card test. If you held a US green card at any time during the calendar year, you are a resident alien for that year. Simple, and it overrides the day-count test below.
The substantial presence test (SPT). You meet it — and become a resident alien — if:
you were present in the US for at least 31 days in the current year, and
your weighted total across three years is 183 days or more, where the current year counts fully, the first prior year counts one-third, and the second prior year counts one-sixth.
Example: 120 days in the US each year for three years gives 120 + 40 + 20 = 180 — you fail the test and remain a nonresident. Add ten more current-year days and you pass.
Exempt individuals. Certain days do not count: F, J, M and Q visa students for their first five calendar years; J and Q teachers/researchers for any two of the past six calendar years; foreign government officials; and a few narrow categories. But exempt status must be claimed — students file Form 8843 every year even with zero income, or the exemption can be challenged.
The closer-connection exception. If you meet the SPT but were present fewer than 183 days in the current year, have a tax home in a foreign country, and can show a closer connection to that country than to the US, you can still be treated as a nonresident — by filing Form 8840. Not available if you have applied for a green card.
Dual-status years. Move to the US mid-year, leave permanently, or get a green card mid-year, and you have a dual-status year: part resident, part nonresident. If you are a resident on December 31, you generally file Form 1040 with a statement for the nonresident period; if nonresident on December 31, Form 1040NR with a statement for the resident period. Dual-status filers cannot use the standard deduction and face restricted filing statuses — plan for this; it surprises almost everyone once.
Which return: 1040NR vs 1040
File Form 1040 if you are a resident alien (green card or SPT): worldwide income, graduated rates on everything, standard deduction, all filing statuses including joint.
File Form 1040NR if you are a nonresident alien and any of these apply: you were engaged in a US trade or business (even with no income); you received FDAP income where tax was not fully withheld at the correct rate; you are claiming a treaty-reduced rate; you owe alternative minimum tax; or you are a foreign-owned single-member LLC owner with Form 5472 obligations. You may skip filing only in narrow cases — e.g., a student with no US-source income beyond an exempt scholarship — but Form 8843 is still required.
The 1040NR has its own architecture: effectively connected income computed at graduated rates (like a 1040), FDAP income on Schedule NEC at 30% or the treaty rate, itemized deductions on Schedule A (limited for nonresidents), and Schedule OI — Other Information — where you disclose residency, days of presence, and treaty positions. Get Schedule OI wrong and treaty benefits can be denied.
The two income buckets: ECI vs FDAP
This distinction is the core of nonresident taxation.
Effectively connected income (ECI) is income connected with a US trade or business: US wages and salaries, income from a US business you run, and certain US-source income tied to that business. ECI is taxed at the same graduated rates as residents. Your employer withholds on it via Form W-2; you reconcile on the return.
FDAP income — fixed, determinable, annual, periodic — is passive US-source income not connected with a trade or business: dividends, interest, rents, royalties, certain gambling winnings. FDAP is taxed at a flat 30%, generally withheld at source by the payer (Form 1042-S documents it). No deductions against it, no graduated rates — unless a treaty says otherwise.
For Indians, the practical pattern: H-1B salary is ECI (graduated rates, W-2 withholding); US dividends in your brokerage account are FDAP (30% withheld, or 25% under the treaty); US bank interest is often exempt for nonresidents under the portfolio-interest rules or treaty.
The India-US treaty: where the real savings are
The Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement between India and the US modifies the default 30% FDAP rate and resolves dual-residence conflicts. Key articles:
Article 11 (Interest): US withholding capped at 15% (with exemptions for government and certain institutional interest), down from 30%.
Article 12 (Royalties and fees for included services):15% for copyright royalties; 20% (reducing per treaty mechanics —) for other royalties and fees for technical/included services.
Article 10 (Dividends): capped at 25%.
Article 21(2): residents of India filing 1040NR may claim the US standard deduction — a benefit almost no other country's residents get, and frequently worth more than the rate reductions.
Tie-breaker rules (Article 4): if both countries claim you as a resident, the treaty assigns residence through a hierarchy — permanent home, centre of vital interests, habitual abode, nationality — letting you file as a nonresident of the US with Form 8833 treaty-based return position disclosure.
Claiming treaty benefits requires the right paperwork: Form W-8BEN given to the withholding agent (so the reduced rate is applied at source), and treaty positions disclosed on the return (Form 8833 for certain positions; Schedule OI always). A common failure: not filing W-8BEN, suffering 30% withholding, then trying to reclaim the difference on the 1040NR — possible, but slower and audit-prone.
FBAR: the form that is not a tax return
The FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) is filed with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network — not the IRS, not with your tax return. You must file if the aggregate value of your foreign financial accounts exceeded $10,000 at any time during the calendar year. For Indians, "foreign" means non-US: your NRE/NRO accounts, Indian savings accounts, PPF (reportable), Indian mutual fund holdings in demat-linked accounts, and any account where you have signature authority — even without a financial interest.
Key points: it is the aggregate that triggers filing — three accounts of $4,000 each ($12,000 total) means all three get reported. The deadline is April 15 with an automatic extension to October 15 — no form needed. Filing is electronic through FinCEN's BSA e-filing system. Penalties are severe and scale with willfulness — and since the Supreme Court's *Bittner* decision, non-willful penalties apply per report, not per account.
FATCA: Form 8938 and the second layer
Form 8938 (Statement of Specified Foreign Financial Assets) is the FATCA form, filed with your tax return. It covers a broader asset set than FBAR — including foreign stock held directly, partnership interests, and certain foreign investments — at higher thresholds:
Year-end
Any time during year
Single, living in the US
$50,000
$75,000
Joint, living in the US
$100,000
$150,000
Single, living abroad
$200,000
$300,000
Joint, living abroad
$400,000
$600,000
Filing FBAR does not satisfy Form 8938, and vice versa — many Indians in the US file both every year. Add Schedule B, Part III (answer "Yes" on line 7a, list India on 7b) whenever you had a foreign account.
PFIC warning: Indian mutual funds are generally Passive Foreign Investment Companies — punitively taxed in the US with Form 8621 reporting per fund. This is the single nastiest surprise for Indians investing at home while US-resident. Direct equities are fine; pooled Indian funds are not. Plan around this before investing, not after.
The filing process — step by step
Step 1 — Determine residency for the tax year
Run the green card test, then the substantial presence test with exempt-individual adjustments. Identify dual-status years and closer-connection eligibility. This determines 1040 vs 1040NR — the foundation everything else rests on.
Step 2 — Gather US income documents
W-2 (wages), 1099-INT/DIV/B (interest, dividends, broker transactions), 1042-S (FDAP income and withholding), K-1s if applicable. Match every document against your records — the IRS has copies of all of them.
Step 3 — Classify each income item as ECI or FDAP
Wages for US work: ECI. Dividends: FDAP. Interest: usually FDAP (check portfolio-interest exemption). Rental income: FDAP by default, but you can elect to treat it as ECI (usually better — graduated rates plus deductions). Business profits: ECI.
Step 4 — Apply treaty positions
For each FDAP item, check the India-US treaty rate (dividends 25%, interest 15%, royalties/FTS per Article 12). Confirm Form W-8BEN was on file with each payer; prepare Form 8833 disclosures for treaty-based return positions (residency tie-breaker, non-standard claims).
Step 5 — Compute the return
1040NR: ECI at graduated rates, FDAP on Schedule NEC at treaty rates, India-resident standard deduction under Article 21(2), limited itemized deductions, Schedule OI completed. 1040: worldwide income including Indian income, foreign tax credit (Form 1116) for Indian taxes paid or FEIE (Form 2555) for qualifying earned income abroad.
Step 6 — Prepare information returns
Form 8843 (exempt individuals — students/scholars, even with zero income). Form 8938 if FATCA thresholds are met. Form 8621 for each PFIC (Indian mutual fund). Form 5472 + pro-forma 1120 for foreign-owned US LLCs. Form 8833 for treaty disclosures.
Step 7 — File the FBAR separately
FinCEN Form 114 through BSA e-filing by April 15 (auto-extended to October 15). List every foreign account, maximum balances converted at year-end rates, joint holders. Download and keep the transcript and acknowledgement.
Step 8 — File, pay, and calendar next year
E-file or paper-file by April 15 (June 15 automatic for US persons abroad; Form 4868 extends to October 15 — extensions extend filing, not payment; interest runs from April 15). Pay any balance due. Then calendar: estimated tax payments if you will owe, W-8BEN renewals (generally every three years), and next year's FBAR.
Deadlines at a glance
Obligation
Due
Extension
Form 1040 / 1040NR
April 15
Form 4868 → October 15
US persons living abroad
June 15 (automatic)
Form 4868 → October 15
FBAR (FinCEN 114)
April 15
Automatic → October 15
Form 8938
With the tax return
With the return's extension
Form 8843
With return / by return due date
—
State returns
Varies (often April 15)
Varies
The India side: don't forget the other return
US filing is half the job. If you are resident in India (ROR), India taxes your worldwide income — including US wages and dividends — with foreign tax credit for US taxes paid (Form 67 in India, filed before the Indian return). If you are RNOR or NR in India, India taxes only India-source income. Coordinate the two: the treaty prevents double tax, but only if both returns are filed consistently and credits are claimed properly on each side. Mismatched residency positions — resident in both countries without invoking the tie-breaker — is how double taxation actually happens.
Estimated taxes — the pay-as-you-go trap
The US runs a pay-as-you-go system, and nonresidents are not exempt from it. If your withholding will not cover your liability — common with FDAP income where the payer withheld at 30% but you will claim a lower treaty rate, or with ECI business profits that have no withholding at all — you may need quarterly estimated payments on Form 1040-ES (NR). Underpayment triggers interest even if you pay in full by April 15. The safe harbours: pay at least 90% of the current year's tax, or 100% of the prior year's tax (110% at higher incomes), through withholding plus timely quarterly estimates. Calendar the four due dates — typically mid-April, mid-June, mid-September and mid-January — because estimated-tax interest is one of those quiet costs that compounds while nobody is watching.
Common mistakes we see
Assuming no filing is needed because "tax was already withheld." Withholding is not filing — you file to reconcile, claim treaty rates, and get refunds.
Missing Form 8843. F-1/J-1 students with zero income skip it; the exempt-individual claim then has no paper trail.
Forgetting the FBAR. The $10,000 aggregate threshold catches far more people than expect — NRE + NRO + a savings account easily crosses it.
Treating Indian mutual funds as harmless. PFIC rules make them punitively taxed; direct Indian equities are far cleaner for US persons.
No W-8BEN on file. Suffering 30% withholding that the treaty would have cut to 15–25%.
Filing 1040 when 1040NR was correct (or vice versa) — wrong standard deduction, wrong income scope, wrong disclosures.
Ignoring state taxes. California, New York and others have their own residency rules and returns; federal filing does not cover them.
Forgetting India. US compliance done, Indian return missed — or foreign tax credit (Form 67) not claimed in India.
How ComplyKart helps — and what we do not do
We prepare and file US federal returns (1040 and 1040NR) for Indian clients, run the residency analysis (SPT, exempt individuals, dual-status, treaty tie-breaker), classify ECI vs FDAP, apply India-US treaty positions with proper disclosure, prepare FBAR and FATCA filings, handle PFIC reporting, and coordinate with your Indian return so foreign tax credits are claimed on the right side.
What we do not do: we do not advise concealing foreign accounts or income — FBAR and FATCA penalties make that arithmetic suicidal. We are not a US law firm and do not advise on immigration consequences of tax positions. And we do not file state returns in states where we do not practice — we will tell you when you need local counsel.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
25 answers from our consultants.
You pay for our expert's time — document checking, filing, follow-ups — not the government. The government fee goes to the government; our fee is for the work we do so you don't have to figure it out yourself.
Depends on your income sources. Salary + one house + other income: ITR-1. Business or profession: ITR-3 or ITR-4 (presumptive). Companies: ITR-6. Filing the wrong form gets your return marked defective — we pick the right one.
Belated returns attract a fee (₹5,000, or ₹1,000 if income is below ₹5 lakh), you lose the right to carry forward most losses, and interest accrues under Sections 234A/B/C. File on time — it's free to be punctual.
In a belated return, most Chapter VI-A deductions (80C, 80D etc.) are not allowed. That's real money left on the table. Another reason the deadline matters.
TDS is not your final tax — it's an advance. You might have paid too much (claim a refund) or too little (pay the balance). Plus, the ITR is your income proof for visas, loans and government tenders.
A day-count formula: 31+ days in the US this year AND 183+ weighted days over three years (this year fully + 1/3 of last year + 1/6 of the year before). Meet it and you are a US tax resident; certain student/teacher visa days are excluded.
ECI (effectively connected income) is tied to a US trade or business — like US wages — and taxed at graduated rates. FDAP is passive income — dividends, interest, rents — taxed at a flat 30%, reducible by treaty (dividends 25%, interest 15% under the India-US treaty).
The US federal income tax return for nonresident aliens. It taxes effectively connected income at graduated rates, FDAP income at 30% or the treaty rate (Schedule NEC), and requires Schedule OI disclosing your residency position, days of presence and treaty claims.
Generally no — nonresident aliens cannot. The exception: residents of India can claim it under Article 21(2) of the India-US tax treaty, a benefit almost no other nationality gets. It is often the single most valuable treaty provision for Indian filers.
FinCEN Form 114, filed electronically with FinCEN (not the IRS). Required if your non-US financial accounts aggregated over $10,000 at any point in the year — including NRE/NRO accounts, Indian savings accounts and PPF. Due April 15, automatically extended to October 15.
FBAR (FinCEN 114) is filed with FinCEN, threshold $10,000 aggregate, covers accounts. Form 8938 is filed with your tax return, has much higher thresholds ($50,000–$600,000 depending on status and residence), and covers a broader set of foreign assets. Most Indians in the US above the thresholds file both.
It caps withholding: dividends 25% (vs 30%), interest 15%, royalties/fees for technical services 15–20%. It gives Indian residents the 1040NR standard deduction. And its tie-breaker rules resolve dual-residence conflicts. Claims need Form W-8BEN with payers and disclosure on the return.
Usually Form 1040NR (students are exempt individuals for five calendar years, so generally nonresidents) plus Form 8843 every year — even years with no income. OPT wages are ECI taxed at graduated rates. FICA exemption generally continues while you are a nonresident alien.
A Passive Foreign Investment Company — and most Indian mutual funds qualify. The US taxes PFICs punitively (excess-distribution regime) with per-fund Form 8621 reporting. Direct Indian equities are not PFICs. If you are a US tax person, prefer direct equities or US-domiciled funds for market exposure.
The annual statement exempt individuals (F/J/M/Q students and scholars, among others) file to claim their exempt days under the substantial presence test. Required every year, even with zero US income. Without it, the IRS can count your days and reclassify you as a resident.
A year in which your residency changes — you move to the US, leave permanently, or get a green card mid-year. Part of the year is taxed under resident rules, part under nonresident rules. You file 1040 (resident at year-end) or 1040NR (nonresident at year-end) with a statement covering the other period, with restricted deductions and filing statuses.
Often yes. States like California and New York have their own residency tests and returns, and federal filing does not satisfy them. Some states do not follow federal treaty provisions. Check each state where you lived or earned income.
At 30% flat FDAP withholding by default, reduced to 25% under the India-US treaty if you have Form W-8BEN on file with the broker. The 1042-S documents the withholding; you report it on Schedule NEC of the 1040NR.
The treaty prevents double taxation: US residents claim a foreign tax credit (Form 1116) for Indian taxes paid; Indian residents claim credit in India (Form 67) for US taxes paid. File both returns consistently — credits only work when each side's return reflects the same income.
The certificate of foreign status you give to US withholding agents (employers, brokers, banks) so they apply the correct treaty withholding rate instead of the default 30%. Generally valid for three calendar years; renew it or withholding reverts to 30%.
Severe. Non-willful violations carry a penalty per report (adjusted annually for inflation); willful violations can reach the greater of $100,000 or 50% of the account balance per violation. Since *Bittner v. United States* (2023), non-willful penalties apply per FBAR report rather than per account.
E-filing for 1040NR has historically been limited — many nonresidents still paper-file, mailing to the IRS service centre in Austin, Texas. Some authorised e-file providers now support 1040NR; confirm before assuming. Paper filing means longer processing — file early if you expect a refund.
Possibly. If you retain US-source income (dividends, rental property, deferred compensation), you generally still file 1040NR. If you surrendered your green card, expatriation rules (Form 8854, exit tax for covered expatriates) may apply. And if you are now Indian-resident, coordinate the Indian return with foreign tax credits for any US tax paid.
Yes, if you had US-source income — typically FDAP like dividends, interest, rents or royalties — and tax was not fully withheld at the correct treaty rate, or you want to claim a refund. You would file Form 1040NR as a nonresident alien. Pure bank interest exempt under treaty/portfolio-interest rules may not require filing.
Usually Form 1040. H-1B holders generally meet the substantial presence test and are resident aliens, taxed on worldwide income. Your first partial year in the US and your final year if you leave permanently are often dual-status years with special rules.
What clients say about working with us
Real stories from businesses we've worked with.
Trademark Registration“
Our Trademark was applied in all the classes with a short span of time by Complykart Trademark Experts and I can say the level of expertise and commitment they carry is remarkable. It's an A+ from my side. We are now sticking to ComplyKart only.
Company Registration“
I found the professionalism of the staff at complykart.com, a pleasure to work with. As a foreigner to India, they took the time to explain the documentation and assisted in every question I raised. I was pleased that complykart.com made it easy for my Business.
Merger & Acquisition“
Trust, Commitment, Dedication and responsiveness are the best things with ComplyKart. Thanks for handling our Merger assignment with so much care. After my business disputes, complykart handles all things with own sense of understanding.
Senior Consultant · ESOP, Trademark & General Advisory · 14+ years experience
Pankaj Jain is a senior consultant covering ESOP structuring, trademark and IP protection, accounting advisory and legal documentation. With the broadest practice at the firm, he handles the matters that don’t fit neatly in one box.
Last reviewed: 16 November 2026
Get a free consultation
Talk to a ComplyKart professional about US Tax Return Filing. The first consultation is free.