Five steps, no guesswork — you always know exactly what comes next. Tap a step to see what it involves.
12345
You pay securely. Payment is confirmed instantly, and your receipt with the written fee breakup lands in your inbox.
Overview
Most companies meet internal audit for the first time the way they meet most compliance — by crossing a threshold and discovering the requirement already applies. A private company grows past ₹200 crore in turnover, or draws down a ₹100 crore working-capital facility, and suddenly Section 138 requires it to appoint an internal auditor. The instinct is to treat it as another filing to manage. That instinct wastes the most useful governance tool the Companies Act gives a growing company.
The statutory audit looks backward once a year and tells shareholders whether the financial statements were true and fair. Internal audit works forward and inward through the year: it tests whether the controls that produce those financial statements actually work, whether the company's processes do what the policy manuals say, and whether risks — fraud, leakage, non-compliance, operational failure — are being managed before they become losses. A good internal audit function finds the weak reconciliation, the unmonitored vendor master, the branch that stopped following the credit policy, months before any of it shows up in the numbers.
This page covers the full framework: who must appoint an internal auditor, who can serve, what the audit covers, how it is scoped and reported, how it interacts with the statutory audit, what it costs, and how ComplyKart sets it up for you.
Is internal audit mandatory for your company? — the Rule 13 test
Section 138(1) says prescribed classes of companies must appoint an internal auditor. Rule 13 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014 prescribes these classes:
1. Every listed company. No thresholds, no exceptions.
2. Every unlisted public company meeting any one of these in or during the preceding financial year:
Paid-up share capital of ₹50 crore or more; or
Turnover of ₹200 crore or more; or
Outstanding loans or borrowings from banks or public financial institutions exceeding ₹100 crore at any point of time; or
Outstanding deposits of ₹25 crore or more at any point of time.
3. Every private company meeting either of these:
Turnover of ₹200 crore or more during the preceding financial year; or
Outstanding loans or borrowings from banks or public financial institutions exceeding ₹100 crore at any point of time during the preceding financial year.
Note what is absent for private companies: there is no paid-up capital leg and no deposits leg. A private company with ₹60 crore of paid-up capital but modest turnover and borrowings is not caught. The test is applied on the preceding financial year's figures — cross the line in FY 2024-25, and the appointment is required for FY 2025-26.
The existing-company transition: a company already covered when the provisions commenced had six months from commencement to comply. For companies crossing thresholds later, the appointment should be in place for the financial year following the year in which the threshold was crossed — boards that wait until the statutory auditor asks about it in March are already late.
Who can be the internal auditor
Section 138(1) is deliberately broad: the internal auditor "shall either be a chartered accountant or a cost accountant, or such other professional as may be decided by the Board to conduct internal audit of the functions and activities of the company." Three points matter:
Practice is not required. Unlike the statutory auditor, the internal auditor need not be in practice. A CA or CMA employed by the company can serve — the Act expressly says the internal auditor "may or may not be an employee of the company."
The Board decides "other professional." For specialised areas — IT systems, engineering processes, EHS — the Board can appoint a professional from that discipline. The appointment is a Board decision, recorded in the minutes.
Independence is functional, not structural. An employee can be the internal auditor, but cannot audit their own work. The head of accounts cannot be the internal auditor of the accounts function. Where the role sits in the organisation chart matters: reporting to the CFO who owns the processes being audited defeats the purpose. Best practice — and the expectation where an Audit Committee exists — is a direct reporting line to the committee.
The one hard prohibition: Section 144(b) bars the statutory auditor from rendering internal audit services to the company. The roles must be separate persons or firms, always.
What internal audit covers — scope and methodology
Rule 13's Explanation provides that the Audit Committee of the company, or the Board, shall in consultation with the internal auditor formulate the scope, functioning, periodicity and methodology for conducting the internal audit. In practice, a well-scoped internal audit covers:
Financial controls testing. Are reconciliations performed and reviewed? Do payment authorisations follow the delegation matrix? Are journal entries supported and approved? This is the layer that keeps the statutory audit clean — the internal auditor tests through the year what the statutory auditor will test at year-end.
Operational audits. Procurement, inventory, sales and collections, payroll, capex — the processes where money and materials move. The internal auditor traces transactions end to end, checking that the documented process matches the actual process.
Compliance audits. Tax filings, labour law registers, FEMA filings, industry licences — the internal auditor verifies that the compliance calendar is being followed and that filings are on time, long before the secretarial auditor or statutory auditor arrives.
IT and systems audits. Access controls, segregation of duties in the ERP, change management, backups, cybersecurity basics. As companies digitise, this has become the fastest-growing part of the internal audit plan.
Fraud and forensic reviews. Surprise cash counts, vendor-master reviews, related-party transaction testing, whistle-blower complaint investigation. The internal auditor is usually the first professional to see a fraud — which is why the reporting line must bypass the people who might be committing it.
Risk-based planning. Mature functions do not audit everything every year. They maintain a risk register, score processes by inherent risk and control strength, and build a rolling three-year plan that covers high-risk areas annually and lower-risk areas on rotation. The annual internal audit plan is approved by the Audit Committee.
The reporting rhythm — what the Board actually receives
The Act does not prescribe a report format, which is both a freedom and a trap. A professional internal audit reporting rhythm looks like this:
Engagement letter and annual plan. Approved by the Audit Committee or Board at the start of the year, setting out scope, coverage, timelines and resource plan.
Periodic reports. Typically quarterly: findings rated by severity (critical, high, medium, low), with management responses, agreed action plans, owners and target dates.
Follow-up and closure tracking. Every finding stays open until the agreed action is verified as implemented. The follow-up report — showing what got fixed and what did not — is often more valuable than the original findings.
Annual summary to the Board. Overall assessment of the control environment, repeat findings, systemic themes, and the plan for the next year.
What good reporting looks like: each finding states the criteria (what should happen), the condition (what was found), the cause, the effect or risk, and a practical recommendation. Reports that only list problems without rating severity or proposing fixes get filed and forgotten. Reports that quantify exposure — "unreconciled vendor balances of ₹4.2 crore, of which ₹68 lakh is over 180 days" — get acted on.
Internal audit vs statutory audit — the distinction that matters
This is the section prospects search for, and the confusion is genuine because both involve auditors looking at the company's books. The differences are structural:
Purpose. Internal audit improves controls and processes for management's benefit. Statutory audit provides independent assurance to shareholders on the financial statements.
Timing. Internal audit is continuous — quarterly cycles, surprise checks, ongoing testing. Statutory audit is annual and backward-looking.
Appointment. The Board appoints the internal auditor; shareholders appoint the statutory auditor at the AGM.
Independence. The internal auditor may be an employee; the statutory auditor must be an independent external CA.
Output. Internal audit reports go to the Audit Committee or Board and are not filed publicly. The statutory audit report goes to shareholders and is filed with the ROC via AOC-4.
The firewall. Section 144 prohibits the statutory auditor from doing internal audit work — the assurance on the financials must come from someone who did not design or operate the controls being assured.
How they reinforce each other: a strong internal audit function reduces statutory audit effort and cost — the statutory auditor can rely on tested controls rather than expanding substantive testing. CARO 2020 makes this explicit: the statutory auditor must report on whether the company has an internal audit system commensurate with its size and business. Companies without one get an adverse CARO comment that every lender reads.
The Audit Committee's role
Where an Audit Committee is required (Section 177), it owns the internal audit relationship: it formulates the scope in consultation with the internal auditor, reviews the findings, monitors follow-up, and evaluates the function's performance. The committee meets the internal auditor independently of management — this private session is where sensitive findings surface. In companies without a committee, the Board performs these functions directly, and the internal auditor should still have a direct line to the Board, not only to the executive team.
Penalties for non-appointment
Section 138 itself prescribes no specific penalty, so the general penalty under Section 450 applies: the company and every officer in default are liable to a penalty of ₹10,000, with a further ₹1,000 per day for continuing contravention. That sounds modest — until a ROC adjudication order, a lender's due-diligence query, or a CARO adverse comment turns it into a reputational and commercial cost far exceeding the fine. Taxmann reported a case where a company and its directors paid ₹3 lakh in adjudication penalties for failing to appoint an internal auditor — the fine is the least of it.
Timeline — setting up internal audit in your company
Week 1–2: Board assesses Rule 13 applicability on the preceding year's figures; resolves to appoint.
Month 2: Risk assessment and annual audit plan prepared; approved by the Audit Committee or Board.
Quarterly: Fieldwork cycles; reports issued with rated findings and agreed actions.
Ongoing: Follow-up verification; closure tracking; annual summary to the Board.
For a company crossing the threshold this year, the appointment and first plan should be complete before the new financial year begins — the function needs a full year of coverage to be meaningful.
Fees — what internal audit costs
Unlike the statutory audit, internal audit fees scale with the depth of coverage, not just company size:
Small mandated companies: ₹1,00,000–₹3,00,000 per year for a focused quarterly program covering core financial controls.
Mid-size companies: ₹3,00,000–₹10,00,000, rising with locations, branches and process complexity.
Large / listed companies: ₹10,00,000 upward; full co-sourced or outsourced functions with dedicated teams.
Outsourcing the function to a CA firm is the most common model for companies between ₹200 and ₹1,000 crore of turnover — it buys senior expertise without building a department. Above that scale, companies typically build an in-house team led by a chief audit executive, sometimes co-sourced with a firm for specialist areas like IT audit.
Advantages of a functioning internal audit
Fraud gets caught early, not at year-end
Most corporate frauds are discovered through internal controls and tip-offs, not through the statutory audit. A functioning internal audit — with surprise checks, vendor-master reviews and a working whistle-blower channel — is the control most likely to surface a fraud while the amounts are still recoverable.
The statutory audit gets cheaper and faster
When the statutory auditor can rely on internal audit's control testing, substantive procedures shrink. Companies with mature internal audit functions consistently report shorter statutory audit fieldwork and fewer year-end surprises — which is also when audit fee negotiations go best.
CARO compliance without firefighting
CARO 2020 requires the statutory auditor to comment on the adequacy of the internal audit system. A documented, functioning internal audit is the difference between a clean CARO clause and an adverse remark that lenders and investors read.
The Board sees reality, not reports
Management reporting tells the Board what management wants it to know. Internal audit tells the Board what is actually happening — the branch that stopped following the credit policy, the procurement split designed to dodge approval limits. Independent assurance to the Board is the governance value no MIS can provide.
Regulatory and lender confidence
Banks with large exposures increasingly ask about internal audit coverage before renewing facilities. Regulators in financial sectors mandate it outright. A functioning internal audit is a credibility asset in every external conversation.
Process improvement, not just policing
The best internal audit functions do not only find failures — they find inefficiencies. Duplicate controls, manual workarounds that an ERP configuration could eliminate, approval chains that add weeks without adding assurance. The recommendations that save money earn the function its keep.
Documents and access the internal auditor needs
Organisation chart, delegation of authority matrix and approval limits
Process manuals, SOPs and policy documents for covered areas
ERP access (read-only) with user-role listings and change logs
Trial balance, ledgers, bank statements and reconciliations
Vendor and customer master data with creation and modification logs
Payroll registers, attendance and leave records
Statutory filing calendar with challans and acknowledgements
Board and committee minutes relevant to the audit scope
Prior internal audit reports with action-taken status
Whistle-blower complaints and investigation records
Access is the engagement's oxygen. An internal auditor denied timely access cannot deliver the plan — the engagement letter should record the company's obligation to provide records within agreed timelines.
How ComplyKart helps
Applicability assessment. We test your company against Rule 13 on the preceding year's figures and give you a clear yes-or-no with the working — no ambiguity, no surprises in March.
Function setup. Engagement letter drafting, auditor selection support (in-house hire vs outsourced firm), reporting-line design so the function reports to the Audit Committee or Board, not to the people it audits.
Risk-based annual plan. We build the risk register, score processes, and prepare the annual audit plan for Audit Committee approval — coverage that matches your risk, not a template.
Execution support. Where you outsource, we manage the firm's delivery: plan adherence, report quality, finding severity ratings, and follow-up discipline.
Closure tracking. We run the action-taken register — every finding tracked to verified closure, with ageing reports for the Audit Committee.
CARO readiness. We ensure the internal audit documentation satisfies what the statutory auditor needs for the CARO internal-audit clause.
What we do not do. We do not serve as your statutory auditor alongside internal audit work — Section 144 prohibits the combination, and we keep the firewall absolute. We do not suppress findings or soften severity ratings to please management; the function's value is its independence.
What happens after the function is set up
First 90 days: Risk assessment complete, annual plan approved, first quarterly cycle underway. The first report typically surfaces the easy wins — unreconciled balances, missing approvals, access-control gaps.
First year: Full coverage of the annual plan. The follow-up discipline is established — management learns that findings do not expire, they get closed. The statutory auditor begins relying on control testing.
Year two onward: The function matures from finding failures to preventing them. Repeat findings should trend to zero; the plan shifts toward emerging risks — new systems, new business lines, new regulations.
Recurring compliance
Annual: Rule 13 applicability re-tested on the preceding year's figures; annual audit plan approved by the Audit Committee or Board; appointment or re-appointment of the internal auditor.
Quarterly (typical): Audit cycles executed; reports issued with rated findings; follow-up on prior actions.
Event-based: Scope changes for new business lines or systems; special reviews on whistle-blower complaints or suspected fraud; reporting to the Board on critical findings as they arise.
Common mistakes companies make
Appointing the statutory auditor's firm for internal audit. Section 144 prohibits it — the appointment is void and both engagements are compromised.
Letting the internal auditor report to the CFO. The function then audits its own boss's processes. The reporting line must go to the Audit Committee or Board.
Treating it as a tick-box. An internal auditor who issues one thin report a year satisfies the letter of Section 138 and none of its purpose — and the CARO comment will say so.
No follow-up discipline. Findings without closure tracking are expensive paper. The value is in verified remediation.
Scoping it too narrow. Limiting internal audit to financial controls while IT access, procurement and compliance go unaudited leaves the largest risks uncovered.
Starting in March. The function needs a full year of coverage. Appointing the auditor in the last quarter and expecting a meaningful annual plan is theatre.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
21 answers from our consultants.
You pay for our expert's time — document checking, filing, follow-ups — not the government. The government fee goes to the government; our fee is for the work we do so you don't have to figure it out yourself.
Yes, if it meets the Rule 13 thresholds: turnover of ₹200 crore or more in the preceding financial year, or outstanding loans or borrowings from banks or public financial institutions exceeding ₹100 crore at any point in the preceding year. Below those thresholds, it is voluntary — but still valuable.
A Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant (in practice or not), or any other professional decided by the Board. The internal auditor may be an employee of the company.
No. Section 144 expressly prohibits the statutory auditor from providing internal audit services to the company. The two roles must be held by different persons or firms.
The Audit Committee, or the Board where there is no Audit Committee. The scope, periodicity and methodology are formulated by the committee or Board in consultation with the internal auditor.
Internal audit is a continuous, management-oriented review of controls and processes reporting to the Board; statutory audit is the annual independent examination of financial statements reporting to shareholders. One works through the year to prevent problems; the other certifies the year-end outcome.
Internal audit examines internal controls, processes and risk management. Secretarial audit (Section 204) examines compliance with corporate laws and is conducted by a Practising Company Secretary, reported in Form MR-3. They are complementary, not substitutes.
No. Internal audit reports go to the Audit Committee or Board and are not filed with the Registrar. Only the statutory audit report travels to shareholders and the ROC (via AOC-4).
The Act does not fix a frequency — the Audit Committee or Board decides in consultation with the internal auditor. Quarterly cycles are the most common rhythm, with continuous auditing in larger companies.
The general penalty under Section 450 applies: ₹10,000 plus ₹1,000 per day of continuing default, on the company and every officer in default. Adjudication orders have imposed higher amounts, and the CARO adverse comment carries its own commercial cost.
Yes. Section 138 expressly permits a Cost Accountant — in practice or in employment — to conduct internal audit.
The Rule 13 classes apply by company type and thresholds, not by Section 8 status. A Section 8 company that is listed, or that crosses the applicable thresholds for its class, must appoint an internal auditor.
Financial controls (reconciliations, authorisations, journal controls), high-value operational processes (procurement, inventory, collections), statutory compliance tracking, and IT access controls. The plan should be risk-based, not a copy of last year's checklist.
A strong internal audit function lets the statutory auditor rely on tested controls, reducing substantive procedures, shortening fieldwork and cutting year-end surprises. CARO 2020 requires the statutory auditor to comment on the internal audit system's adequacy.
Companies between ₹200 and ₹1,000 crore of turnover most commonly outsource to a CA firm — senior expertise without building a department. Larger companies typically build an in-house team, sometimes co-sourced with a firm for specialist areas.
Instead of auditing everything annually, the function maintains a risk register, scores each process by inherent risk and control strength, and builds a rolling plan — high-risk areas every year, lower-risk areas on rotation. The Audit Committee approves it.
No — an auditor cannot audit their own work. An employee serving as internal auditor must be independent of the functions being audited, with a reporting line outside those functions.
It formulates the scope in consultation with the internal auditor, approves the annual plan, reviews findings, monitors follow-up to closure, evaluates the function's performance, and meets the internal auditor independently of management.
It covers fraud prevention and detection controls — surprise checks, vendor-master reviews, related-party testing, whistle-blower investigation. It is typically the first professional layer to see a fraud, which is why its reporting line must bypass potential suspects.
Organisation charts, delegation matrices, SOPs, ERP access, ledgers and reconciliations, vendor and customer masters, payroll records, filing calendars with acknowledgements, board minutes, prior reports and whistle-blower records. The engagement letter should record access timelines.
The Rule 13 test applies on the preceding financial year's figures. Cross the threshold in FY 2024-25, and the appointment is required for FY 2025-26 — the appointment and first audit plan should be in place before the new financial year begins.
What clients say about working with us
Real stories from businesses we've worked with.
Trademark Registration“
Our Trademark was applied in all the classes with a short span of time by Complykart Trademark Experts and I can say the level of expertise and commitment they carry is remarkable. It's an A+ from my side. We are now sticking to ComplyKart only.
Company Registration“
I found the professionalism of the staff at complykart.com, a pleasure to work with. As a foreigner to India, they took the time to explain the documentation and assisted in every question I raised. I was pleased that complykart.com made it easy for my Business.
Merger & Acquisition“
Trust, Commitment, Dedication and responsiveness are the best things with ComplyKart. Thanks for handling our Merger assignment with so much care. After my business disputes, complykart handles all things with own sense of understanding.
Senior Consultant · ESOP, Trademark & General Advisory · 14+ years experience
Pankaj Jain is a senior consultant covering ESOP structuring, trademark and IP protection, accounting advisory and legal documentation. With the broadest practice at the firm, he handles the matters that don’t fit neatly in one box.
Last reviewed: 16 November 2026
Get a free consultation
Talk to a ComplyKart professional about Internal Audit. The first consultation is free.