Five steps, no guesswork — you always know exactly what comes next. Tap a step to see what it involves.
12345
You pay securely. Payment is confirmed instantly, and your receipt with the written fee breakup lands in your inbox.
Income Tax Scrutiny Cases: How We Handle Them
A scrutiny notice lands in your inbox on a Tuesday evening. Your stomach drops. Here is the first thing to know: a scrutiny case is the tax department asking questions, not delivering a verdict. Most scrutiny cases end exactly where they started — with your returned income accepted — provided the questions get complete, consistent answers on time.
Think of it the way a doctor thinks of a follow-up test. The first report (your filed return) showed something worth a closer look — a number that did not line up with the department's other data about you. The follow-up (scrutiny) is the department running the confirming test. People get into trouble in scrutiny the same way they get into trouble with follow-up tests: by skipping the appointment, by answering vaguely, or by bringing half the records.
This page explains how scrutiny works, what the department is actually looking for, how we build a reply that closes the case, and what happens when the officer proposes an addition you disagree with. Every procedural statement here is checked against the statute as it stood in October 2026.
Why your return got picked
Nobody at the department sits reading returns at random and thinking yours looks interesting. Selection is driven by the department's risk management system, which compares your return against the trail of third-party information the department already holds about you:
AIS and TIS mismatches. Your Annual Information Statement and Taxpayer Information Summary compile bank interest, securities transactions, mutual fund activity, property deals, and high-value spending reported by third parties. When your return shows less than the AIS shows, that is the single most common scrutiny trigger.
TDS and Form 26AS gaps. Salary, interest, or professional receipts on which TDS was deducted but which never appeared in your return.
GST return cross-checks. For businesses, turnover declared in GST returns is compared with turnover in the income tax return. A gap here invites questions fast.
High-value transactions. Property purchases, large cash deposits, foreign remittances, and share transactions above internal thresholds.
Deduction and exemption claims. Large HRA, 80C, 80D, or capital gains exemption claims get verified against the underlying documents.
Compulsory scrutiny categories. CBDT publishes annual parameters — survey cases, search-linked cases, and returns with specific risk flags are picked up as a matter of policy.
Knowing the trigger matters because it tells us what the officer will ask. A case picked for an AIS mismatch is about reconciliation; a case picked for a deduction claim is about evidence. The reply strategy is different in each.
The two-regime reality: old Act and new Act
India is mid-transition between two tax statutes, and scrutiny cases straddle both. Get the section numbers right for your year or the reply cites the wrong law:
Assessment years up to 2026-27 are governed by the Income-tax Act, 1961. Notices for these years cite Sections 143(2), 142(1), and 143(3). The Income-tax Act, 2025 has saving provisions that keep old-year proceedings under the old Act.
Tax year 2026-27 onwards (AY 2027-28 onwards) are governed by the Income-tax Act, 2025. Scrutiny provisions moved into Section 270: the notice is Section 270(8), the three-month limitation is Section 270(9), and the assessment order is Section 270(10). The 142(1) questionnaire became Section 268(1); best judgment assessment moved from Section 144 to Section 271.
The procedure — the portal, the faceless units, the deadlines, the way you reply — is unchanged. Only the section numbers on the notice change. When we draft a reply, we match the citations to the year the notice belongs to.
The notices, decoded
The 143(2) notice (or 270(8)). This is the selection notice. It says your return has been picked for scrutiny and names the assessment year. It does not say what is wrong — often it names no specific issue at all. Two checks the moment you receive one: (1) verify it on the e-filing portal under e-Proceedings — genuine notices appear there; (2) confirm it carries a valid DIN. A notice without a DIN, per CBDT Circular 19/2019, has no legal standing, and we have seen cases closed on this ground alone.
The 142(1) questionnaire (or 268(1)). This is where the real work starts. The officer asks for specific things — bank statements, books of account, purchase and sale deeds, investment proofs, explanations for specific entries. The questionnaire has a deadline, usually 15 to 30 days. This reply becomes part of the permanent record of your case, so it needs to be precise, complete, and internally consistent.
The show cause notice with draft order. If the officer is not satisfied with your replies and proposes to add income or disallow a claim, you get a draft assessment order plus a show cause notice. This is your last structured chance to argue before the final order. Treat it as the most important document in the case.
The final assessment order. This concludes scrutiny. It states the assessed income, the tax and interest payable, and whether penalty proceedings are initiated. If you disagree, the remedies — rectification, appeal, revision — start here.
How a scrutiny case actually flows
Step 1 — Verify the notice is genuine and valid
We log into the e-filing portal, open e-Proceedings, and confirm the notice exists there with a matching DIN and a digital signature from the National Faceless Assessment Centre. We check the assessment year, the section cited, and the response deadline. If the DIN is missing or the notice never appeared on the portal, we challenge validity before doing anything else — there is no point building a defence against a notice that does not legally exist.
Step 2 — Identify what triggered the case
We pull your AIS, TIS, and Form 26AS for the year and reconcile them against the filed return line by line. In most cases the trigger reveals itself within an hour: an interest entry you forgot, a securities transaction the broker reported gross, a property deal where the circle rate exceeded your sale price. Knowing the trigger lets us answer the question the officer is actually asking instead of dumping every document you own on the portal.
Step 3 — Assemble the evidence file
We build a single indexed evidence file mapped to the questionnaire: bank statements for the year, the specific contracts or deeds in question, investment and deduction proofs, books of account for businesses, and the computation that ties each document to the return. Every document is clearly named and referenced in the reply by page or annexure number. Officers decide cases on paper; a reply that makes the officer's verification easy gets decided faster and more favourably.
Step 4 — Draft and file the questionnaire reply
The reply follows a discipline: answer each question in order, state the fact, cite the document, and reconcile the number. Where there is a genuine mismatch — say the AIS shows gross sale consideration and your return shows net gain — we explain the difference with the computation, not with adjectives. The reply is filed through e-Proceedings before the deadline, and we keep the acknowledgement. If the deadline is genuinely unworkable, we request an extension before it expires, not after.
Step 5 — Handle follow-up queries
Faceless assessment often runs in rounds. The Assessment Unit may route your reply through a Verification Unit or Technical Unit, and supplementary queries come back through the NFAC. Each round narrows the issues. We respond to each in the same structured way, and we track what has been asked and answered so nothing is repeated or contradicted across rounds.
Step 6 — Respond to the show cause notice and draft order
If a draft order proposes additions, we dissect it: which addition, on what evidence, under which section, and what was missed. The show cause reply is part legal argument, part factual correction. We address each proposed addition separately, attach the supporting evidence, and cite the applicable provisions and settled positions. This is also the stage to request a personal hearing by video conference if the issues need oral explanation — the Delhi High Court has been clear that the right to be heard effectively survives the faceless format.
Step 7 — Review the final assessment order
When the order arrives, we check three things immediately: whether it was passed within the limitation period, whether it addresses the replies you filed, and whether the computation is arithmetically correct. A surprising number of orders contain computation errors or ignore filed submissions — both are grounds for rectification or appeal.
Step 8 — Choose the remedy if you disagree
The options, in the usual order of consideration: rectification for mistakes apparent from the record (wrong arithmetic, a filed document the order overlooked); appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) or the National Faceless Appeal Centre for disputed additions; stay of demand where the tax demand is contested and recovery would cause hardship; revision in the narrow cases the statute permits. For transfer pricing cases and foreign companies, the Dispute Resolution Panel route under Section 144C applies instead, with its own draft-order and objection procedure.
Timelines that actually bind
Stage
Time limit
Scrutiny notice (143(2) / 270(8))
Within 3 months of the end of the FY in which the return was filed
Reply to 142(1) questionnaire
As specified in the notice, typically 15–30 days
Completion of assessment
Generally 12 months from the end of the relevant assessment year
Appeal against assessment order
30 days from receipt of the order
Rectification application
Within 4 years from the end of the FY in which the order was passed
For AY 2025-26 returns filed in FY 2025-26, the outer date for the department to serve the scrutiny notice was 30 June 2026. If your notice arrived after the limitation date for your year, that is a jurisdictional defect — flag it before engaging on merits.
The document checklist we work from
For individuals: the filed return and computation, Form 16/16A, bank statements for all accounts for the year, AIS/TIS/26AS, investment and deduction proofs (80C, 80D, HRA rent receipts and landlord PAN where applicable), capital asset purchase and sale documents, and loan statements.
For businesses: audited financials, tax audit report (3CD), GST returns (GSTR-1, 3B, 9) reconciled with books, stock registers, major purchase and sale invoices, expense ledgers for the heads under query, and director/partner capital account statements.
The single most useful document in most cases is a reconciliation statement — AIS versus return, GST turnover versus books — prepared before the officer asks for it. It shows the case is under control.
Common additions and how they are defended
Unexplained cash deposits or credits. The officer treats unmatched bank credits as unexplained income. The defence is source-tracing: each credit matched to a declared receipt, a loan, a transfer between own accounts, or a genuine gift with the donor's details.
Bogus or inflated purchases and expenses. For businesses, the officer may disallow expenses lacking invoices or paid to unverifiable parties. The defence is the invoice trail, bank payment proof, and the business connection of the expense.
Capital gains recomputation. The officer may substitute the circle rate for your sale price or dispute your cost of acquisition. The defence is the registered deed, the cost records, and — for pre-2001 assets — the registered valuer's report.
Deduction disallowances. HRA without rent proof, 80C investments not actually made, business deductions without nexus. The defence is the underlying proof, filed before the assessment closes.
Transfer pricing adjustments. For companies with international transactions, the TPO may adjust prices to arm's length. The defence is the transfer pricing documentation and comparability analysis — and where the adjustment stands, the DRP route.
In each case the principle is the same: the officer proposes, you evidence. Additions survive where evidence is thin; they fall where the paper trail is complete.
Penalties and interest in scrutiny
Tax found due in scrutiny carries interest under Sections 234A (late filing), 234B (short advance tax), and 234C (deferred instalments) — these apply mechanically once additional income is assessed. Penalty is separate: Section 270A penalises under-reporting and misreporting of income, with higher rates for misreporting. Penalty proceedings are independent of the assessment — even where you accept the addition, the penalty notice needs its own reply, and reasonable cause remains a defence. We handle penalty replies as a distinct workstream, not an afterthought.
How ComplyKart helps — and what we do not do
We take the case from the notice to the final order: notice verification, trigger diagnosis, evidence assembly, questionnaire replies, show cause responses, hearing preparation, order review, and appeals where warranted. A chartered accountant leads the technical drafting; a company secretary coordinates the record and deadlines so nothing slips.
What we do not do: we do not advise anyone to ignore a notice, manufacture documents, or backdate evidence — that converts a winnable scrutiny case into a prosecution risk. We do not guarantee outcomes; no honest professional can. And we do not file appeals for the sake of filing them — if the addition is correct on law and facts, we tell you so and help you close the case cleanly.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
20 answers from our consultants.
You pay for our expert's time — document checking, filing, follow-ups — not the government. The government fee goes to the government; our fee is for the work we do so you don't have to figure it out yourself.
Depends on your income sources. Salary + one house + other income: ITR-1. Business or profession: ITR-3 or ITR-4 (presumptive). Companies: ITR-6. Filing the wrong form gets your return marked defective — we pick the right one.
Belated returns attract a fee (₹5,000, or ₹1,000 if income is below ₹5 lakh), you lose the right to carry forward most losses, and interest accrues under Sections 234A/B/C. File on time — it's free to be punctual.
In a belated return, most Chapter VI-A deductions (80C, 80D etc.) are not allowed. That's real money left on the table. Another reason the deadline matters.
It is the officer's questionnaire asking for specific documents, books of account, or explanations. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025 it is Section 268(1). Your reply becomes part of the permanent case record, so it needs to be precise and consistent.
No. Non-compliance leads to best judgment assessment under Section 144 (Section 271 under the new Act), where the officer estimates your income without your evidence. That estimate is rarely in your favour.
Yes. All scrutiny is faceless — notices, replies, documents, and hearings happen electronically through the e-filing portal. Personal hearings are conducted by video conference when requested and approved.
Bank statements, the filed return and computation, AIS/TIS/26AS, investment and deduction proofs, property transaction documents, and for businesses, audited financials, tax audit reports, and GST returns reconciled with books.
When the officer proposes additions or disallowances, a draft order is prepared setting out the proposed changes with reasons, accompanied by a show cause notice. Your reply to it is the last structured opportunity to contest the additions before the final order.
The DRP is a collegium of senior officers that hears objections to draft orders in transfer pricing cases and cases of foreign companies (Section 144C). It issues binding directions to the Assessing Officer within 9 months of receiving objections.
You can seek rectification for apparent mistakes, file an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) or NFAC within 30 days, or apply for stay of the disputed demand. The right remedy depends on whether the dispute is factual, computational, or legal.
Not necessarily. Many cases are selected on system parameters — an AIS mismatch you already know about, a high-value transaction, or a large deduction claim. Selection is the start of verification, not a finding of fault.
Scrutiny examines the return you filed for that year. Reassessment (Section 147/148) reopens a completed year because income is believed to have escaped assessment. They are different proceedings with different notices and limitation periods.
The officer can call for information relevant to the assessment year under scrutiny. Roving enquiries into unconnected years can be objected to — the questionnaire must have a nexus with the year being assessed.
Refunds are generally held back while scrutiny is pending, since the final assessed income may differ from the returned income. Once the order is passed, the refund — if any — is processed with interest.
Interest under Sections 234A/B/C applies mechanically on additional tax assessed. Section 270A penalises under-reporting and misreporting of income through separate penalty proceedings, where reasonable cause is a defence.
You are not legally required to engage one, but scrutiny replies involve reconciliations, legal drafting, and deadline management where professional handling materially changes outcomes. The cost of a poorly drafted reply usually exceeds the professional fee many times over.
Under Section 144 (Section 271 under the new Act), if you fail to file the return, ignore notices, or do not comply with the questionnaire, the officer assesses your income to the best of his judgment — without your evidence. It is the consequence of non-cooperation, not a separate charge.
The procedure is the same — faceless notices, e-Proceedings replies, draft orders. Only the section numbers changed: scrutiny notice under 270(8), limitation under 270(9), assessment order under 270(10). This applies to tax year 2026-27 onwards.
A taxpayer cannot revise an assessment order; the revision power under Section 264 belongs to the Principal Commissioner and is invoked in limited circumstances. Your remedies are rectification, appeal, and stay — chosen based on the nature of the dispute.
What clients say about working with us
Real stories from businesses we've worked with.
Trademark Registration“
Our Trademark was applied in all the classes with a short span of time by Complykart Trademark Experts and I can say the level of expertise and commitment they carry is remarkable. It's an A+ from my side. We are now sticking to ComplyKart only.
Company Registration“
I found the professionalism of the staff at complykart.com, a pleasure to work with. As a foreigner to India, they took the time to explain the documentation and assisted in every question I raised. I was pleased that complykart.com made it easy for my Business.
Merger & Acquisition“
Trust, Commitment, Dedication and responsiveness are the best things with ComplyKart. Thanks for handling our Merger assignment with so much care. After my business disputes, complykart handles all things with own sense of understanding.
Direct Tax Specialist · Income Tax & TDS · 8+ years experience
Ritik Gupta handles ComplyKart’s direct tax practice — income tax returns for companies, LLPs and individuals, TDS filings, advance tax planning and assessment proceedings. He keeps clients penalty-free through every assessment year.
Last reviewed: 16 November 2026
Get a free consultation
Talk to a ComplyKart professional about Income Tax Scrutiny Cases. The first consultation is free.