IN BRIEF

CARO 2020 is the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020, issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs under Section 143(11) of the Companies Act, 2013. It requires the auditor of a company it covers to report on 21 matters — from fixed assets, loans and statutory dues to fraud, internal audit and CSR — in an annexure to the auditor's report, for years commencing on or after 1 April 2021.

CARO 2020 is the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 — the MCA's 21-point checklist your statutory auditor reports on alongside the main audit opinion. It applies to audits of financial years starting on or after 1 April 2021. Private companies fall inside it unless they are a one person company, a small company, or pass all four private-company exemption conditions.

Most directors never read the second half of their own audit report. The main opinion gets the attention — a clean opinion, a qualified one — and the annexure stapled behind it gets filed away unread. That annexure is CARO. And in the FY 2025-26 audit season now under way, it is the part most likely to catch a company unprepared. Not because the auditor found fraud. Because nobody kept the file the auditor needed.

I have sat through enough audit closings to know how this goes. The auditor asks for the title deeds. The deeds are in a director's personal locker, in his father's name. The auditor asks for the quarterly stock statements filed with the bank. Finance sends the provisional ones. The auditor asks for the whistle-blower log. There is no log. None of this is fraud. All of it lands in the CARO annexure.

What CARO 2020 actually is

CARO stands for the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order. The 2020 version was issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs under Section 143(11) of the Companies Act, 2013, after consulting the National Financial Reporting Authority, and notified as S.O. 849(E) on 25 February 2020. It replaced CARO 2016 and widened the auditor's checklist from 16 matters to 21.

It was first meant to apply to financial years starting 1 April 2019. The MCA deferred it twice — by S.O. 1219(E) on 24 March 2020 and by S.O. 4588(E) on 17 December 2020 — and it finally applies to audits of financial years commencing on or after 1 April 2021. Every audit since FY 2021-22 carries it, including the FY 2025-26 audits happening now.

Think of it the way you would think of a vehicle's fitness check. The main audit opinion is the verdict: fit to drive, or not. CARO is the 21-point inspection sheet stapled to it — brakes, lights, papers, fuel — each item ticked, each failure noted. A failed item does not cancel the verdict. It sits on the record for anyone who reads it.

That is the right way to hold the idea in your head, because CARO is not a second opinion. It is an annexure to the auditor's report — usually headed "Annexure A" — referred to in the "Report on Other Legal and Regulatory Requirements" section, signed with the main report, and carrying the auditor's UDIN. Each of its 21 clauses is a factual statement: this was checked, this is what was found. Where the answer is unfavourable or qualified, paragraph 4 of the Order forces the auditor to state the basis for it. A bare "no" is not a CARO answer.

Does CARO apply to your company?

The Order applies to every company, including a foreign company, except five kinds: a banking company, an insurance company, a company licensed under Section 8, a one person company, a small company — and a private company that satisfies all four of these conditions at once:

  • The company is not a subsidiary or a holding company of a public company.
  • Its paid-up capital plus reserves and surplus is not more than ₹1 crore as on the balance sheet date.
  • Its total borrowings from any bank or financial institution do not exceed ₹1 crore at any point of time during the financial year.
  • Its total revenue, as disclosed in Schedule III including revenue from discontinuing operations, does not exceed ₹10 crore during the financial year.

Read those four conditions again, slowly. Three different measurement dates hide inside one sentence. The capital test is taken on the balance sheet date. The borrowings test runs across the whole year — a company that touched ₹1 crore of bank borrowing for a fortnight in July is inside CARO for that year, whatever its position at year end. The revenue test is for the full year. And the exemption is cumulative: fail any one condition and CARO applies in full.

Take two companies I will call by made-up names, because the arithmetic matters more than the name. Mehta Trading Pvt Ltd has paid-up capital of ₹80 lakh and reserves of ₹40 lakh — ₹1.2 crore together at 31 March 2026. Its revenue is ₹8 crore and its borrowings never crossed ₹60 lakh. It fails the first limb by ₹20 lakh. CARO applies. Sharma Services Pvt Ltd has capital plus reserves of ₹70 lakh, borrowings that never went above ₹80 lakh, revenue of ₹6 crore, and no public-company parent. It passes all four. No CARO annexure. The difference between the two is ₹20 lakh of reserves and nothing else.

Then there is the change most guides still miss. From 1 December 2025, a small company means paid-up capital up to ₹10 crore and turnover up to ₹100 crore, under G.S.R. 880(E). The old limits were ₹4 crore and ₹40 crore. A company sitting between the old and new limits — say, ₹6 crore of capital and ₹60 crore of turnover — was inside CARO for FY 2024-25 and outside it for FY 2025-26. One honest caveat: the turnover limb is worded on the preceding financial year, and the MCA has issued no clarification on how the transition year is tested. If your company sits near the line, confirm the position with your auditor rather than assuming it. Our guide to the new small-company limits works through that test in full.

Two more boundaries worth stating plainly. CARO applies only to companies under the Companies Act, 2013. An LLP, a partnership firm or a sole proprietorship is outside it entirely, however large it is. And on consolidated financial statements, the Order does not apply at all — except clause 3(xxi), which asks the auditor to report the qualifications or adverse remarks in the CARO reports of the companies consolidated, naming each company and the paragraph number.

The 21 clauses at a glance

Paragraph 3 of the Order lists the 21 matters. Each clause applies only where the matter exists for the company — a company with no deposits reports clause 3(v) as not applicable, with a reason. Grouped by theme, with the number that decides each answer:

ClauseWhat the auditor checksThe number that matters
3(i)Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets — records, physical verification, title deeds, revaluation, benami proceedingsRevaluation of 10% or more, by a Registered Valuer
3(ii)Inventory and working capital limits — physical verification, quarterly returns to lendersDiscrepancies of 10% or more per class; limits above ₹5 crore
3(iii)Loans, investments, guarantees and security given — terms, repayment, overdue amounts, evergreening, loans repayable on demandOverdue for more than 90 days
3(iv)Compliance with Sections 185 and 186 on loans, investments, guarantees and security—
3(v)Deposits and deemed deposits — RBI directions and Sections 73 to 76—
3(vi)Cost records, where maintenance is specified under Section 148(1)—
3(vii)Statutory dues — regularity of undisputed dues, arrears, and dues unpaid on account of a disputeArrears outstanding more than 6 months
3(viii)Income surrendered or disclosed in tax assessments but not recorded in the books — and whether it is now recorded—
3(ix)Borrowings — defaults lender-wise, wilful defaulter status, end use of term loans, short-term funds used for long-term purposes, funds for group obligations, loans on pledge of group securities—
3(x)Money raised — IPO or further public offer applied for its purpose; preferential allotment or private placement under Sections 42 and 62—
3(xi)Fraud by or on the company, Form ADT-4 under Section 143(12), whistle-blower complaints consideredAny fraud noticed or reported — no threshold
3(xii)Nidhi companies — Net Owned Funds to deposits ratio, unencumbered term deposits10% unencumbered term deposits
3(xiii)Related party transactions — Sections 177 and 188, and disclosure under the applicable accounting standards—
3(xiv)Internal audit — a system commensurate with size and nature, and whether the internal auditors' reports were considered—
3(xv)Non-cash transactions with directors or persons connected with them — Section 192—
3(xvi)RBI registration under Section 45-IA, activity without a Certificate of Registration, Core Investment Company criteria and the number of CICs in the group—
3(xvii)Cash losses in the financial year and in the immediately preceding year, with amounts—
3(xviii)Resignation of the statutory auditors — whether the incoming auditor considered the issues raised by the outgoing auditor—
3(xix)Ability to meet liabilities existing at the balance sheet date as they fall due within one year — ratios, ageing, management plansOne-year horizon
3(xx)CSR — unspent amounts transferred to a Schedule VII fund or a special accountWithin 6 months of year end
3(xxi)CARO qualifications or adverse remarks in the companies included in consolidated statementsConsolidated statements only

Five clauses that trip companies up

Title deeds not in the company's name — clause 3(i)(c). The auditor must report every immovable property whose title deed is not held in the company's name, in a table: description, gross carrying value, who holds it, whether that person is a promoter, director or their relative or employee, how long it has been held, and the reason — and whether it is in dispute. Factory land bought in a director's name years ago, a property inherited and never mutated, a flat registered to a promoter: all of it lands here. Leased property is outside this sub-clause. Owned property held in someone else's name is not.

Quarterly returns that do not agree with the books — clause 3(ii)(b). Where the company was sanctioned working capital limits above ₹5 crore at any point in the year, on the security of current assets, the auditor checks whether the quarterly returns filed with the bank agree with the books of account. Stock statements filed in a hurry with provisional numbers are the classic mismatch. The bank does not mind a provisional figure. The auditor has to report it.

Statutory dues unpaid for more than six months — clause 3(vii). Undisputed dues — GST, provident fund, ESI, income tax — must be deposited regularly, and any arrears outstanding for more than six months from the date they became payable get named. Dues not deposited on account of a dispute are listed separately, with the amounts and the forum. One sentence in the Order is worth reading twice: a mere representation to the concerned department shall not be treated as a dispute. Writing a letter to the department does not convert an unpaid due into a disputed one.

Fraud, and the ₹1 crore that everyone gets wrong — clause 3(xi). The auditor reports any fraud by the company or on the company noticed or reported during the year, with its nature and amount. There is no ₹1 crore threshold in CARO. The ₹1 crore figure belongs to Section 143(12): fraud involving ₹1 crore or more must be reported by the auditor to the Central Government in Form ADT-4; below that amount it goes to the audit committee or the board. Several guides conflate the two and tell directors that small frauds need not be reported. They do — just to a different address. The clause also asks whether the auditor considered whistle-blower complaints received during the year. A company with no whistle-blower mechanism has nothing to show here, and that absence speaks for itself.

Can the company pay its bills for the next year — clause 3(xix). This one is frequently misdescribed as a going concern opinion. It is narrower and sharper: on the basis of the financial ratios, the ageing of receivables and payables, and the auditor's knowledge of the board and management plans, is there any material uncertainty that the company can meet its liabilities existing at the balance sheet date as and when they fall due within one year? It is the clause a bank reads first when a limit comes up for renewal.

What a CARO remark actually means

A remark in the CARO annexure is not a fine. The Order creates no penalty for a remark itself, and a remark can sit alongside a clean audit opinion — the two are separate statements. But the annexure travels with the auditor's report into Form AOC-4, and from there onto the public record. Anyone can check a company's MCA master data and then pull its filed documents. A bank renewing a working capital limit reads the annexure. An investor writing a cheque reads it. A buyer in due diligence reads it before signing. And because paragraph 4 requires the auditor to state the basis for every unfavourable answer, the remark arrives with its reasons attached.

So the question is never "how do we get the auditor to soften the wording". The auditor signs the annexure with a UDIN and answers for it. The question is what the remark says about the company, and whether the underlying issue is fixed before the next audit. Most CARO remarks are documentation failures, not dishonesty — a missing deed, an unreconciled statement, a due left unpaid for seven months. Documentation failures are fixable. They are only expensive when they are discovered in the last week of the audit.

Before your auditor arrives: the preparation checklist

Run this list a month before the audit starts, not the week it ends. Every item on it is something the auditor will ask for under one of the 21 clauses:

  • Title deeds file: every immovable property, in whose name, with the clause 3(i)(c) table ready — including the reason and the period held.
  • Fixed-asset register with quantitative details, and the record of physical verification done during the year.
  • Inventory count sheets, and a reconciliation of any discrepancy of 10% or more for each class.
  • Quarterly statements filed with banks, reconciled to the books before the auditor asks.
  • Loan register: every loan, investment, guarantee and security given, with terms, repayment schedules and a list of amounts overdue for more than 90 days.
  • Statutory dues ledger: month-wise deposits, arrears outstanding more than six months, and disputed dues with the forum and the amount.
  • Related-party register with the Section 177 and 188 approvals behind each transaction.
  • Whistle-blower complaints received during the year, and how each one was dealt with.
  • Cash-loss working for the current year and the immediately preceding year.
  • CSR workings and proof of transfer of unspent amounts, if Section 135 applies to the company.
  • Minutes showing the internal auditors' reports were placed before the board or the audit committee.

Four of these — title deeds, quarterly returns, the wilful defaulter position and the CARO reports of group companies — need information from outside the finance team, and each one can take a fortnight. Ask for them in the first week of the engagement. That is the single most useful piece of audit planning in this entire guide.

Should you handle this yourself?

Running the applicability test is a director's job and takes ten minutes with the balance sheet in front of you. Preparing for the 21 clauses is a professional's job — your company secretary and your chartered accountant, working from the checklist above, before the auditor arrives. If CARO applies to your company, talk to your auditor before the year ends, not after it. The cheapest CARO annexure is the one with nothing to report, and the way to get it is to have the file ready when the question is asked.

If you want that preparation handled properly, our secretarial audit team reviews the same records CARO tests — title deeds, related-party approvals, statutory dues and board processes — and our annual filing team makes sure the auditor's report, CARO annexure included, reaches the ROC on time. The FY 2025-26 filing window is open now: AOC-4 without additional fee till 31 December 2026 and MGT-7 till 31 January 2027 under General Circular 05/2026. Our compliance fee calculator will show you the exact additional fee if you miss those dates. For the audit itself, read our guide to who needs a secretarial audit under Section 204 — the two exercises share most of their paperwork.

Frequently asked questions

Does CARO 2020 apply to LLPs?
No. CARO applies only to companies under the Companies Act, 2013. An LLP, a partnership firm or a sole proprietorship is outside the Order entirely, however large its turnover. LLPs have their own audit thresholds under the LLP Act, 2008 — turnover above ₹40 lakh or contribution above ₹25 lakh — which are a different test altogether.

My company is a small company now — do I still need CARO for FY 2025-26?
If the company meets the new limits — paid-up capital up to ₹10 crore and turnover up to ₹100 crore — from 1 December 2025, it is a small company and sits outside CARO. But the turnover limb is worded on the preceding financial year and the MCA has issued no clarification on the transition year, so a company near the line should confirm the position with its statutory auditor before assuming the exemption.

What happens if the statutory auditor resigns mid-year?
Clause 3(xviii) asks whether the incoming auditor considered the issues, objections or concerns raised by the outgoing auditor. Separately, the resigning auditor files Form ADT-3 with the company and the ROC within 30 days of resignation, and the board must fill the vacancy within 30 days, with the appointment approved at a general meeting within three months. A resignation does not pause CARO — the new auditor reports on the full year.

Is a CARO remark the same as a qualified audit opinion?
No. The audit opinion is the auditor's verdict on whether the financial statements give a true and fair view. CARO is an annexure of factual statements on 21 specified matters. A company can carry a CARO remark and a clean opinion at the same time, and a qualified opinion can sit beside a clean CARO annexure. They answer different questions.

Does CARO apply to consolidated financial statements?
Only clause 3(xxi). The auditor of the consolidated statements reports whether the CARO reports of the companies included in the consolidation carry any qualifications or adverse remarks, naming the companies and the paragraph numbers. The other 20 clauses are reported only on standalone financial statements.